Skip to main content

Charles Mingus - How Low The Earth

Although harmony by itself generally does not receive copyright protection, '07 Tempo Music Inc. v. Famous Music Corp. indicated that harmony might suffice. Duke Ellington's estate, namely his son Mercer and the Famous Music Corporation, sued the executor of Billy Strayhorn's estate claiming that Strayhorn did not have a protected interest in his harmonic contributions to subsequent arrangements of Satin Doll, a song by Ellington... Examining the issue of harmony, Judge Sand acknowledged harmony as inherently derivative because it usually accompanies an already created melody. Rejecting the Ellington Estate's argument that harmony cannot itself give rise to a copyright, the court held that, although certain chords occur inevitably from a given melody, composers especially in jazz and contemporary music sometimes make especially creative use of harmony, which necessarily influences the mood, feel and sound of a piece.

Instead of relying on the proposal of novel results as the standard for originality, the court deemed the creative process as most important, leading to its conclusion that harmony can, as a matter of law, be the subject of copyright. The court's refusal to grant summary judgment indicated the court's more expansive view of copyright protection.

In some cases, a portion of a musical work will prove important enough so that copying, or nearly copying, it will warrant a finding of copyright infringement. Plaintiffs can face a difficult burden when claiming copyright infringement in this manner. Generally, if a portion of one work proves to be quantitatively and qualitatively similar to another work, it will infringe the original work.


Charles Mingus - How Low The Earth
  • Arranger by: Louis Lubella, Charles Mingus
  • Recorded on: December 12, 1953
  • Released in: 1954

"Accomplished on the double bass, cello and piano, Charles Mingus was well known as a band leader, recording artist, producer, and a highly innovative composer. Mingus earning the reputation of the Angry Man of American jazz."

See previous Song of the Day

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Moondog - Behold

The history of jazz has been one of fusion. Its musicians and composers have continually drawn upon a huge range of different musics to create the rich and diverse tapestry that is world jazz today. Jazz is an evolving tradition of music making. And how often, in the life stories of individual jazz musicians, do we see these same patterns operating at microcosm? The richness of Turkish music and culture sometimes seems at odds with its turbulent and cruel history. In 1979... the country suffered its third military take over in thirty years... Every kind of music was in Turkey at that point. But it was not appreciated. To understand the culture of the country, with those three military takeovers, Turkey could not go anywhere. Musically, it was very difficult. But things were beginning to happen. Traditional Turkish music is essentially monophonic, rich in melody and rhythm but with little by way of harmony. The contrast with western music, with its beautiful harmonies but rhythmic weakn...

Veronica Swift - A Little Taste

There has always been an uncomfortable tension between rhythm and blues and rock and roll, a cyclical influence that vacillates between inspiration, appropriation and separation. Popular music has broken off into categories of rock, pop, country, and R&B, each with their own origin stories. But R&B and rock, usually codified as vastly different, Black and white styles, have long been intertwined in ways our historical memory may have us forget.  Despite the innovation that comes from separation, rock and R&B always find their way back to each other. In recent years, rock veterans have turned to the genre’s classics for inspiration. Queens of the Stone Age veered from their typical hard rock with 2017’s Villains, a dance y album inspired by frontman Josh Homme’s love of 1920s jazz and swing, other Black genres that laid the groundwork for the popular music of today. The whitewashing of rock’s history has oversimplified music’s malleability and silenced the voices of Amer...

The Gap Band - The Sun Don't Shine Everyday

The Gap Band - The Sun Don't Shine Everyday Genre: RnB Released in: 1984 Duration: 5:14 "The Gap Band was most successful when working with producer Lonnie Simmons, with four consecutive gold records. Their party train soon slowed to a stop. They reformed in the 90s and occasionally toured and attempted a comeback album." See Previous Song of the Day